Thursday, April 29, 2010

Twits Tweeting

So, I am not a fan of tweeting.  I don't really give a shit if you found a deal on a pair of shoes or just took a major crap.  So anyway I remember a year or so ago at the state of the union address there was a big splash made of the congressmen who were tweeting during the address.  I find this insulting.  You are there to do the entirely difficult job of writing laws for a diverse and complicated country.  While I agree that the state of the union has become a pep rally for the majority party, tweeting during the address, come on.

Anyway, I haven't thought much about it until I came across this article on newsweek.com.  As you know I am a big fan of factcheck.org.  I wish more people visited there.  I think it will help a lot, however it involves reading so that is out for 90% of the populace.  However maybe there is an app for that... that tweets... while you are reading... on the toilet...

Anyway, apparently congressmen are still tweeting.  The article goes into several 'factual difficulties' our 'intelligence impaired' congress have had, recently, on both sides.  What is difficult for me to understand is this: legislating is difficult, do you really think 140 characters is enough when the health care bill was like a million words long?  So you can't craft a bill that people can actually read but you feel like tweeting 140 characters is enough to explain the problems with health care reform or the motives of the opposition?  Come on people.  I would actually prefer if you all spent your time writing simpler laws rather than tweeting, leave that to the unemployed.  If you continue to tweet hopefully you will join them in 6 more months.

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Take two shots and call me in the morning

To start out with I would like to say that a lot of time is wasted in documentaries by people walking in hallways, talking on phones, or typing on computers.  I mean these aren't hard things, why do I need to watch someone do it.  The more hilarious part is that the people are trying not to laugh while doing it.

(I would like to say at the start that I am discussing the content of the video only and not information that was not contained in the video.  I personally would choose to vaccinate my children as I have seen no scientific evidence to the contrary.  However this does not have any effect on my discussion of the validity of the arguments presented.)

Anyway, so Frontline had a new video this week about vaccines.

As always I love Frontline, I don't always agree with the way they present material nor the material they leave out but in the end I feel like Frontline is in general a productive thing to watch.  This video is worth watching even though I am going to tear apart a couple of things here.  (The Wikipedia article on vaccines is here.)  The video is about people who don't want to vaccinate their kids and the reasons for it.  (Wikipedia article is here.)

I have to say, and this is a common complaint about all people throughout all time, is that people do not understand logic, statistics, and rational argument.  I don't want to specifically say person X is an idiot, I mean these are not simple topics to master however the lack of skill in these areas are causing significant problems in society.  For instance take the mom in the Frontline video from Oregon who is trying to rationalize not vaccinating her kids.  I will say that she has a valid question, 'When is the disease gone so that we can stop vaccinating against it,' however this is her justification for not vaccinating her kids: 'There hasn't been a case in X years in the United States.'  However during this time thousands of people die outside the United States.  This is an example of an illogical conclusion, this is like me saying no one ever gets hit by cars because I have never been hit by a car.  Additionally this more complicated due to the herd immunity populations in the United States has had in recent years though pockets of problems are popping up.

I also want to directly attack a common problem with cause and effect.  It is common today (and in the video this is pointed to early) that science and the benefits thereof are subdued or wrong if the discovering party makes money off the discovery.  In the video the Doctor who discovered the 'R' in the MMR vaccine was directly questioned about this.  I don't think he did any favors to himself by dodging the question however the question is stupid to begin with.  The vaccine is provided to children because the NIH, CDC, FDA, etc. say it is safe and prevents disease.  Does the profit motive matter here?  Does the fact that he made money from it mean the vaccine doesn't work?  No.  Now some people may dislike the idea of paying someone a profit on something that is 'required' for life but in reality you do this all the time, food, shelter, etc.  Don't think your landlord is a charity organization.  Luckily this was quickly glossed over as I feel like it was a general distraction.

Next we are looking at a statistical problem in the video.  The video spends a lot of time discussing the link between autism and vaccines (specifically Thimerosal and Mercury as possible culprits).  Now here is the problem, and it is stated later in the video about minute 35:00.  It is stated that parents noticed their children regress at this specific time, when the vaccine was given.  The guy was like, science can't tell us why this happened though non-scientific evidence from the parents said it happened because of the shot.  Well this is what the scientific method is for, to prove both positive or negative outcomes.  The research showed there was no or significant evidence against a link between the vaccines and autism.  I think the video states it pretty clearly that there is an average age when autism is diagnosed and that happens to be during the time that a lot of vaccines are given.  Correlation does not equal causation, it is that simple, you have to prove causation (and correlation).

I feel like a lot of problems and poor communications could be cleared by a more effective understanding of these principals of rationality, logic, and statistics.  It seems pretty difficult to have a functioning society without these and so many people lack them.  I feel especially blessed that I have a solid understanding of those but it also took many years to develop a good grasp of any of them.

So now I will discuss briefly (after tearing into the anti-vaccine camp) the positive points they made.  Yes, it is important that these concerns are studied.  Yes, it is important that we spend resources to identify problems.  Yes, (my opinion is) you should have choice in determining what happens to your children, however, I do not feel you should assume you can know everything just because 'you read something'.  I would say challenge your doctor by asking important questions however remember to practice intellectualism and defer to the person with the most expertise in the area.  It is sad when children have bad things happen to them but we need to as parents, and as a society look at the problem through a scientific lens and find out what the real cause of the problem is, half-guesses and assumed omnipotence are counter-productive.

(I strongly suggest watching the video and surfing through the Wikipedia articles as the discussion is very interesting.  I would also add the discussion on the Frontline website is interesting.  It is obvious that not all information could be presented in 55 minutes and some people bring up valid points and additional information.  I think both sides should remember that we are all looking for the answer we just may have different paths to get there.)

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

Unbelievable

Here is a video on Anderson Cooper 360 which is incredible.  These people just walk by as a man is dying.  What is amazing to me is that the women didn't call for help.  What is also surprising is that it took the authorities 1 hour to arrive at the scene of the crime (if in fact she was the one who called).  This is incredible.  I actually watched a cop car hit a kid this last week.

Why didn't these people help him?  He was homeless, could that be it?  I have to admit I would think twice before approaching someone on the sidewalk after dark.  It could be a trap.  Criminals are getting more innovative all the time, playing on the good Samaritans is common.  So I can kinda understand walking by.  However I think I would still call someone.  However I can't believe the groups of people walked by.  Pretty incredible.

I have to say that I think the guy in the video is mostly full of crap.  I don't think the 'whatever he called it' is the reason people walked by.  I think it has more to do with what I said.  Also I feel like even if you are just helping the police the amount of time you spend and such is overwhelming.  I don't know if that would prevent me from helping someone who was bleeding, however I may think twice about calling in a bum sleeping on the sidewalk because it just isn't worth the effort to move the bum.

I have to say this is crazy, the people who took pictures should doubly be ashamed of himself.  Just ridiculous.

Sunday, April 25, 2010

Update on GS v. SEC and public opinion

So I posted recently about what the content of the case was against Goldman-Sachs.  I wanted to weight in on the case (I know, surprising).  (For reference here is another article which stands closer to my opinion.)

So here is my thing, these were not average investors.  These people involved in the deal had the sole job of vetting and buying/selling securities of this nature.  They should have known that there was danger.  See here is the issue that most people don't understand: The buyers (all people in these transactions have a seller and a buyer) didn't care.  They were betting that the housing market would go up forever and they just wanted a steady income stream from Paulson for free (since the market would go up).  The bigger issue is that they didn't charge enough for the risk.  If the buyer had charged enough then Paulson would likely have not entered into the transaction either.  I mean Paulson was betting heavily against the grain, almost no one was betting that way at the time, that is why the Synthetic CDO was so cheap and thus why Paulson took it (in an economic sense).  If there were a lot of people betting against the housing market then there would have been more demand and less supply which would have raised prices (i.e. Paulson would have paid more every month to the buyer).  There was little risk to them but a large reward and they were betting it would pay off.

Now look at this the other way.  If the world was different and the market didn't crash then Paulson would have been out a lot of money (well not a lot but out money) and we wouldn't be talking about this.  The issue is that due diligence was not done by the buying party.  As a society we don't like people who bet against stuff.  For instance, take an opposing bet on a craps table and see what happens, you will get a lot of stares.  Why?  Because as a society we want to go long.  Bet for something rather than against so when someone makes money against something we as a society get mad.  I feel like there is a lot of that here.  I mean look at how often congress wants to ban short-sellers.  This is a huge problem, without the ability to bet against a security all the securities will be over valued and the market will be more bubbly and more people would lose money.  We need people to bet against securities and ideas when it makes sense.

Is Goldman-Sachs at fault of anything?  No.  They brought together a buyer and a seller.  They didn't want to hold the buyer's side.  Does it matter than some people bet for and some against in the same company?  No.  Each area is responsible for their own money making and you can bet if the short sellers lost a lot of money they would all be gone just like those who made the securities lost their jobs when the short-sellers were right.  I mean the biggest problem is that people were buying stuff just because it was from Goldman-Sachs, the reputation meant that no one thought about what they are buying.  This is like you going into a store and t he clerk saying you should buy X and then you just buy it because if they sell it it must be good.  Now reputation is a good thing and allow people to make decisions with less information.  However I hope that in the future people will look at that less.

One outcome is that people will be more likely to do their due diligence when buying non-traditional securities.  This can only help us.  The market works best when all people work in their interest and if you don't know what you are buying then you can't do that.

I will say that one hopeful outcome of this is that complex instruments will eventually have smaller disclosure documents and simpler reporting.  I mean who is going to read thousands of pages?  I feel like a standardization of securities in this market would do a lot to help reduce the paper and help the individual buyers and sellers make a better choice.  (If you have money and want to invest in a start-up I have a fabulous idea for a company who can address the importance of derivatives and the transparency needed to create a market.  There is a market and non-government solution to these problems and I know what it is.)

Saturday, April 24, 2010

Island of Solitude

I love surfing the travel sites, knowing that I will never see many of these places unless I win the lotto.  (Come on 1-2-3-4-5-6-(7) make me rich.)  So I came across a really neat page which is the remotest islands you can get to and what is there.  So awesome.  Wish I didn't have to work so I could just explore this world while I am still young and could enjoy it.

Here is the slide show.

A Hilarious Clip about Religion

So in case you didn't hear (who hasn't), the south park guys have been threatened with death threats from an American Muslim group in America.  Well the Daily Show had a fabulous video (and song) to all people who get mad about politics and religion and the differences people have in that arena.  Hilarious.  Make sure you get to the end, the song is hilarious.

The Daily Show With Jon StewartMon - Thurs 11p / 10c
South Park Death Threats
www.thedailyshow.com
Daily Show Full EpisodesPolitical HumorTea Party

Wednesday, April 21, 2010

That Park is going, going, gone

I just have to say I love maps, and that the New York Times and Newsweek always have really good ways of putting together information.  Well here is something I ran across sometime back and I thought you would all enjoy this.  Here is a map of places that are likely to radically change due to climate change.  This is like a who's who of things to see.  Make sure you drive your 6 mpg hummer to these places.  If not you may not make it.  :-)

Its a really neat page, totally check it out.

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Jesus Saves

While I was researching other blog posts I came across an interesting post on seekingalpha.com about saving in China.  I thought I would provide it for reference since a lot of people seem to think economics is black magic (which a lot of it is).  I mean economics is the science of saying why your prediction yesterday was wrong.  However this does a good job of explaining why savings and interest rates are correlated in the US and then goes to provide anecdotal evidence of why the reverse is true in China.  Mostly (IMHO) this is due to the larger safety net in the US and the longer history of 'things working out' in general.  China on the other hand is newly free market and so many people still save like crazy to pay for things that the state doesn't provide.

Alphabet Soup of Goldman-Sachs

So, for those who live under a rock, last week the SEC (those guys who fell down on finding Madoff, ya them) have brought charges against Goldman-Sachs.  Now I know it is common to bash Goldman-Sachs for making money these last couple years especially while everyone else is losing tons of money, however it is important to know that not everyone there is evil.  However it does look like questionable things were happening inside the company.

So what are the charges about?  Well I have collected a couple of interesting links for your review:
  • Article from the Huffington post.  I would strongly suggest starting here.  This article is fairly accessible and does a good job of reviewing the case against Goldman-Sachs and what they did.  I think in general this article is slightly more 'they are evil and meant to be evil in their actions' than this is 'just unfortunate as a product of doing business' article.  I, in general, do not like a lot of the HuffingtonPost.com articles but I thought this did a good job of explaining the problem.
  • From CBS about the breakdown between GS and the SEC.  What I find most interesting is that the commission was split 3-2 on party lines.  Come on people this isn't a partisan issue.  Your job is to protect investors, I really feel like this party lines thing has gone too far when it influences whether or not the SEC brings actions against companies.
  • Europe's Response.  You know when blood is in the water more sharks circle.  Governments always want escape goats especially when they were complacent in the problem to begin with.  With so many problems in Europe (think Greece here), it seems like everyone attacks at the same time.
  • Overview from a blog at seekingalpha.com.  (If you have never been to this site and invest you are doing yourself no favors.)  This site is mostly people blogging about investing and markets so as you can imagine there has been a lot of postings about this.
It will be interesting to see how this all settles out.  This is a major problem for the markets, trust.  If you can't trust the counterparties then markets breakdown (though you can buy insurance against that).  Your broker should have your interests at heart.  It looks like Goldman-Sachs may not, not that this surprises anyone.

I have not decided if on any level either of the options (GS is guilty or not) is a preferable option.  I think it is terrible that some companies are so big that the government can't police them because they don't have the resources to force compliance (it is well known the SEC 'talks' with large companies to find solutions when they cause problems and not sue them since the SEC doesn't have the resources to win).  No one should be above the law but in the US we seem to be ok with the government not policing the largest companies.  This is a good step in the correct direction.

Update:  Had to add a daily show link for this.  :-)

The Daily Show With Jon StewartMon - Thurs 11p / 10c
These F@#king Guys - Goldman Sachs
www.thedailyshow.com
Daily Show Full EpisodesPolitical HumorTea Party

Monday, April 19, 2010

Musings on Conferences

So I have a couple of thoughts on conferences I would like to air out.  I think there is a lot of problems in the current structure as I have seen in my research career.  Some organizations put on better conferences than others, this is not in doubt.  But the general quality of a quality conference is slightly unnerving to me.
  1. The publishable delta is larger than you know.  There is a lot of thinking that the smallest publishable delta should be published (and sought after).  I have problems with this model as it encourages people to do trivial uninterested research in general.  Additionally the smallest publishable delta is larger than most people think.  It is obvious that some institutions are publication machines without any thought on the quality of the research.
  2. Most people give terrible presentations.  This one probably wouldn't surprise most people as a lot of people in general give poor presentations.  Most colleges have a public speaking class that is required, I know I did.  The course was a joke honestly.  This is however a very important skill and it is one that I actually did take away from graduate school partly from my advisor whom I left.  It is important to be able to explain your research to anyone and it is important to describe it clearly.  Most people I have seen recently fail at both of those.
  3. Most people can't write coherent papers.  I am amazed at the poor quality of writing that is accepted in a lot of journals.  I have been an editor a couple of times now and there are occasionally good co-editors, however in general I feel like the reviewers just rubber stamp most work.  Additionally I feel like reviewers should not know who wrote the paper because it biases them.  I mostly feel like my time is wasted when I review papers because my work is larger ignored or unnoticed.  There are good papers and better journals but most are just full of crap (including the 'premiere' journals).
  4. All because you can make a graph of your work doesn't make it interesting, research, or publishable.  I can't tell you how many presentations I have been to where the presentation was just talking about an experiment and not results.  Or some stuff which results with one graph.  Amazing.  There is no peer review of the academic merit there.  Not everything should be published.  While I agree that no result is a result you have to have some reason for someone to care beyond 'I need to publish for my career'.
  5. Fifteen minutes is not long enough for anything.  The common thread I have seen in a lot of conferences is to allow for 15 minute presentations.  You know that isn't enough time.  I really feel like 30 minutes is what is needed (however 15 minutes is more than enough to bore the hell out of me).  No one ever gets done in 15 minutes and no real information can be transferred to the audience in that time.
  6. This follows from the previous one but posters and WAY better than presentations.  I know everyone thinks that presentations are better and more respectable than posters but I love posters both as a presenter and as an observer.  I like talking about the material, being able to move forwards and backwards through the material, not having a time limit, the amount of questions you can address, etc.  I just feel like it is a more effective way to get information across.  However I will say, there are a lot of REALLY bad posters.  If your poster has over 200 words on it you are probably doing something wrong.  I once saw a poster with, I kid you not, 5000 words on it.  Could not believe it, needless to say I didn't read it.
This all comes on the heels of an interesting discussion on slashdot.org about Chinese papers and employees.  I don't actually have any direct experience with the material talked about in the discussion but my experiences with outsourcing are less than glowing.  What is happening to research?  Perhaps I was spoiled because I went to a big name university where I met and interacted with really, really, smart people.  I know people who did interesting and compelling research (though not all).  Perhaps the majority of research is this search for the smallest publishable delta and they fall short.  Seems like a bad thing if it is.