So, I have another pet peeve that annoys me to no end. As the title says, BLUE TOOTH EARPIECES DO NOT MAKE YOU SPECIAL. I would like to say that no one I have ever meet is important enough to have a blue tooth ear piece in their ear while they pick up their dry cleaning or ordering an overpriced glass of water with suspended particles in it. Additionally as has been said by many people, I don't need to hear your conversation, nor do I can what she did, with whom, and where, nor do I care about your uninformed opinion about the president, congress, whatever pet project you have, or whatever your work/union/friends tell you. (I realize the irony if you are reading my blog, it was suppose to be funny.)
Anyway as I was saying, no one is that important. I would also like to add that you can take it out of your ear and interact with real people. However I will say on a plus note that it is refreshing to see some people actually following the law and not talking on the phone without a headset while driving. At least I am assuming this, as I have yet to see someone driving who was talking on the phone using one.
Tuesday, May 5, 2009
Sunday, May 3, 2009
Exposing the Fire of Reverse Discrimination
This has been under the news and I have had a tough time finding articles to support both sides of the case. At the onset I would like to say I find it deplorable that the news media are not discussing this court case as it is huge to the near future of our country. It ranks on the same level as the Michigan Entrance Points case. While the Michigan case was decided (in my opinion) correctly, this situation is just as important. In the current case the issue is whether race should be important to promotion decisions whereas the Michigan case was whether or not race could be considered in entrance decisions.
So let me start with a quick list of publications online that I have read and a quick overview.
If you actually browse the SCOTUS Wiki you will see all the 'friend of the court' (Amicus) briefs you will see a significant amount of 'non color blind' organizations filing briefs. (I personally do not support organizations that make a distinction between people based on skin color, or other minority group, and thus promote that minority without regard to equal protection and fair competition.) These organizations have a significant skin in the court case as they promote various (self-interested) things (like in the Michigan case) where they do not always promote equal protection and no discrimination for ALL races in ALL cases.
The problem is this issue has been made a partisan issue where the conservatives support the oppressed (majority) and the liberals support the color non-blind policies that are suppose to make opportunities more equal (thus provide advantages to the minority). Both sides actually have historically and currently relevant points.
For non-color blind policies:
The real problem with this case is that the case is hardly covered by the media. Instead we worry about a couple of people getting the flu, or what country Jolie is adopting a kid from today. This case has wide reaching consequences and should be scrutinized by all people on all sides of the issue. It seems that since Obama was elected the news media wants to believe that racism is dead. Well it isn't, it just hides itself in plain sight. I'll keep those who read my blog posted on the status of the decision once it is available. I encourage you to read the cites articles and postings as they will help provide a fuller picture of the case.
So let me start with a quick list of publications online that I have read and a quick overview.
- Wikipedia's overview. (Make sure you read the links at the end.)
- Reason.com (Seems to be the only publication that is interested in this case. For reference reason.com is a publication that is decidedly libertarian and decidedly freedom based. I am sure you can predict what side they agree with, they filed a 'friend of the court' brief.) Article.
- SCOTUS Wiki. (This site is cool.) (This has links to all 'friends of the court'. Very cool.)
- SCOTUS Blog. (Another great site.)
If you actually browse the SCOTUS Wiki you will see all the 'friend of the court' (Amicus) briefs you will see a significant amount of 'non color blind' organizations filing briefs. (I personally do not support organizations that make a distinction between people based on skin color, or other minority group, and thus promote that minority without regard to equal protection and fair competition.) These organizations have a significant skin in the court case as they promote various (self-interested) things (like in the Michigan case) where they do not always promote equal protection and no discrimination for ALL races in ALL cases.
The problem is this issue has been made a partisan issue where the conservatives support the oppressed (majority) and the liberals support the color non-blind policies that are suppose to make opportunities more equal (thus provide advantages to the minority). Both sides actually have historically and currently relevant points.
For non-color blind policies:
- Historically the white establishment kept the other races suppressed in America.
- Socially people tend to associate with people of their own race and economic background.
- Most people will not willing change their ways willingly.
- Government intervention in social interactions and business transactions were expanded under the post 'guilded age' (1920's) and so the precedent had been set.
- There may be latent racism and policies should be used to mitigate that.
- Economically these policies help bring up minorities in the population and provide opportunities that may not have been available at the expense of others who may have been more qualified and so these policies represent an inefficiency in the market economy we have (or are suppose to have).
- It is against Martin Luther's dream to make any decision based on race.
- Socially people in most areas of the country are color-blind and other areas have pressure to be more accepting (mostly from government interaction)
- People under the age of 30 are decidedly color neutral on many issues and have friends of all races in huge numbers. Promoting discriminatory policies will hamper these connections and could case a major reversal of these trends as people become more aware of the problems systemic.
- Enforcing color blind policies will disenfranchise those affected by the reverse discrimination. In the Michigan case and this case the people hurt are younger and more apt to encourage change. This disenfranchises people when the roles and opinions they will have in their life are starting to solidify as they have kids. If social engineering is to be attempted it should not be done to disenfranchise the leaders of tomorrow.
- Economically having non color blind policies will lead to lower earnings and lower productivity (since the best candidate didn't get the job, resources are inefficiently allocated) in any corporation. While this case is about government whose only output in general is inefficiency, in an age where taxes are on the raise it is important to not encourage inefficiencies.
"I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character."I think you know who's quote that is. I would like to think that a world like that is possible. However quotas, reverse-discrimination, racism, etc. are not helpful to that vision and I personally believe that the man quoted above would be against reverse discrimination outright. Most especially when they are enforced or allowed by the federal government. I hope this court case is decided appropriately. The reason article paints an optimistic picture for those who dislike racism as it seems that there is a higher probability that the court will side with Ricco in this case. (This is the opinion of the author, who is not a supreme court judge.)
The real problem with this case is that the case is hardly covered by the media. Instead we worry about a couple of people getting the flu, or what country Jolie is adopting a kid from today. This case has wide reaching consequences and should be scrutinized by all people on all sides of the issue. It seems that since Obama was elected the news media wants to believe that racism is dead. Well it isn't, it just hides itself in plain sight. I'll keep those who read my blog posted on the status of the decision once it is available. I encourage you to read the cites articles and postings as they will help provide a fuller picture of the case.
Saturday, May 2, 2009
Twit Post: Why Mensa is ridiculous
(I promise I will get away from twit posting (defined as short posts with little analysis) soon. I have just been really busy.)
This video just highlights what is wrong with the inclusion criteria for Mensa (the group of 'really smart people'). This girl is essentially a memory machine. I think it is horrible that we have reduced the 'intelligence' of a person to their ability to verbally recite things. It is really sad. Should not intelligence be the ability to make connections, to think rationally, to invent or innovate, etc.? When did we get away from that. While I am not saying this girl is not smart, I am saying there is no evidence either way based on this video. (For reference there have been about 4 videos like this recently where a 'smart' kid is brought on and then just shown to be an encyclopedia on something. One I remember was that she knew all the presidents forwards and backwards.)
Now what does this mean for this little girl? Everyone will always be telling her she is smart which is a self-fulfilling prophecy just as much as the converse is. Thus she likely has a more productive and fulfilling life ahead of her as a result of this. The question is, 'For such a trivial trick why not get more kids recognized as "smart" and give them a leg up in life?' I think that is an important question to ask as it returns to the heart of the issue. Now of course if she had devised a new quantum unification theory instead of just reciting facts, well then she wouldn't have even needed the smart term anyway.
This video just highlights what is wrong with the inclusion criteria for Mensa (the group of 'really smart people'). This girl is essentially a memory machine. I think it is horrible that we have reduced the 'intelligence' of a person to their ability to verbally recite things. It is really sad. Should not intelligence be the ability to make connections, to think rationally, to invent or innovate, etc.? When did we get away from that. While I am not saying this girl is not smart, I am saying there is no evidence either way based on this video. (For reference there have been about 4 videos like this recently where a 'smart' kid is brought on and then just shown to be an encyclopedia on something. One I remember was that she knew all the presidents forwards and backwards.)
Now what does this mean for this little girl? Everyone will always be telling her she is smart which is a self-fulfilling prophecy just as much as the converse is. Thus she likely has a more productive and fulfilling life ahead of her as a result of this. The question is, 'For such a trivial trick why not get more kids recognized as "smart" and give them a leg up in life?' I think that is an important question to ask as it returns to the heart of the issue. Now of course if she had devised a new quantum unification theory instead of just reciting facts, well then she wouldn't have even needed the smart term anyway.
Friday, May 1, 2009
Twit Post: Update on Diamonds
Sunday, April 26, 2009
Twit Post: Memo to CNN (and every other news organization)
The following is not news : http://www.cnn.com/2009/WORLD/meast/04/26/clinton.lebanon/index.html
What would be news is if Clinton went to Lebanon and said, 'Look here is how you rig an election....' Come on CNN, real reporting, please. I have pushed cnn.com to the bottom of my read list for the day, everyday. There is just not enough good reporting on there. This is another example. Now the article should read either, 'Clinton says obvious American foreign policy statement,' or 'Clinton outlines plan citing research and precedent on how to run election in Lebanon.' I mean just repeating what we expect her to say is NOT NEWS.
What would be news is if Clinton went to Lebanon and said, 'Look here is how you rig an election....' Come on CNN, real reporting, please. I have pushed cnn.com to the bottom of my read list for the day, everyday. There is just not enough good reporting on there. This is another example. Now the article should read either, 'Clinton says obvious American foreign policy statement,' or 'Clinton outlines plan citing research and precedent on how to run election in Lebanon.' I mean just repeating what we expect her to say is NOT NEWS.
Saturday, April 25, 2009
On a lighter note: Outsourcing
Outsourcing is a very volatile issue in the united states. It is tough to find a black and white solution to what is the best way to approach the entire issue. However in advance of my own posts on the outsourcing epidemic I thought this more lighter discussion on the issue would help lighten the mood.
More American Workers Outsourcing Own Jobs Overseas
My favorite part is the conference call machines talking to each other.
More American Workers Outsourcing Own Jobs Overseas
My favorite part is the conference call machines talking to each other.
Tuesday, April 21, 2009
Special on water in the pudget sound
Frontline tonight was a special on water. I would say at the start Frontline continues it's 6045 part series on depressing shit. I think they need to break it up with a special on why rabbits are cuddly. I mean come on, a happy special sometimes, please. After watching Frontline I think my water is poisoning me, my credit card company is hanging me, my country doesn't listen to me, my representative doesn't know shit, I'm going to pay 90% taxes, Aliens are pulling my brain out through my nose, and my stuffed animals, regardless of what they say, are trying to kill me. Just a couple of specials on kittens, please guys.
The Frontline special is here.
This special was particularly interesting because it featured the Puget sound as an example of poisoned water. The special was talking about the affects of the 1940s on the rivers and the problems that it brings to today. What is interesting is the law which says that land owners can only develop about 60% of their land in King county. I have heard a lot about this recently but did not really understand the entire story behind this law (which is apparently still being challenged through the courts). It was also interesting to hear the other side of the discussion about this law. The people affect, in their opinion, in an adverse and illegal way discussed the consequences of the law on their lives.
Basically this special deals with things that aware Americans already know, our water is poisoning us. Not nearly as quickly as China's water is poisoning them though. The chemicals, medications, sewer water that get dumped into the waterways are poisoning the ecosystems all over the world. As an interesting anecdote I was hiking this weekend by the Puget sound and I saw a long stream of oil just sitting on the water. You know the kind of thing you would see in a rough lake after a storm when all the oil collects in one place. I actually thought, this being democrat heaven, that the sound was actually in good shape. Got my eyes opened.
It is really depressing to think that the world is assailing us on so many sides with clubs and society is more concerned with who some movie star is dating this week. The poisonous waters are slowly rising to cover our homes and the politicians in Washington are more interested in lining their pockets and promoting their narrow-minded view of the world. Really sad.
The Frontline special is here.
This special was particularly interesting because it featured the Puget sound as an example of poisoned water. The special was talking about the affects of the 1940s on the rivers and the problems that it brings to today. What is interesting is the law which says that land owners can only develop about 60% of their land in King county. I have heard a lot about this recently but did not really understand the entire story behind this law (which is apparently still being challenged through the courts). It was also interesting to hear the other side of the discussion about this law. The people affect, in their opinion, in an adverse and illegal way discussed the consequences of the law on their lives.
Basically this special deals with things that aware Americans already know, our water is poisoning us. Not nearly as quickly as China's water is poisoning them though. The chemicals, medications, sewer water that get dumped into the waterways are poisoning the ecosystems all over the world. As an interesting anecdote I was hiking this weekend by the Puget sound and I saw a long stream of oil just sitting on the water. You know the kind of thing you would see in a rough lake after a storm when all the oil collects in one place. I actually thought, this being democrat heaven, that the sound was actually in good shape. Got my eyes opened.
It is really depressing to think that the world is assailing us on so many sides with clubs and society is more concerned with who some movie star is dating this week. The poisonous waters are slowly rising to cover our homes and the politicians in Washington are more interested in lining their pockets and promoting their narrow-minded view of the world. Really sad.
Saturday, April 18, 2009
Twit Post: Non-Breaking News
The title of CNN right now reads:
"BREAKING NEWS: Clinton says she's 'deeply disappointed' by Iran's sentencing of U.S. journalist."
No, I am not going to comment on the content of the message beyond, is this really breaking news? Should not breaking news be like, "Clinton sends in Navy Seals to extract journalist." This is just a comment by someone who is suppose to comment on this stuff. Of course she is not going to be "Woohoo, justice was done." It is just ridiculous. I have seen even more ridiculous stuff in 'Breaking News' on CNN (and other websites, they are all just as bad).
Let us put the following rule in place : "It is only breaking news if it is unexpected, the story is new, or it is a shocking turn of events." We could always apply the other following metric "Would a newspaper in the 1920's have printed an 'extra extra' section, if not then it isn't breaking news." Either of them is fine with me.
News agencies need to be more aware of the stupid things they do to get eye-balls. If they continue I will stop reading CNN all together. I mean they rarely have good news anyway.
"BREAKING NEWS: Clinton says she's 'deeply disappointed' by Iran's sentencing of U.S. journalist."
No, I am not going to comment on the content of the message beyond, is this really breaking news? Should not breaking news be like, "Clinton sends in Navy Seals to extract journalist." This is just a comment by someone who is suppose to comment on this stuff. Of course she is not going to be "Woohoo, justice was done." It is just ridiculous. I have seen even more ridiculous stuff in 'Breaking News' on CNN (and other websites, they are all just as bad).
Let us put the following rule in place : "It is only breaking news if it is unexpected, the story is new, or it is a shocking turn of events." We could always apply the other following metric "Would a newspaper in the 1920's have printed an 'extra extra' section, if not then it isn't breaking news." Either of them is fine with me.
News agencies need to be more aware of the stupid things they do to get eye-balls. If they continue I will stop reading CNN all together. I mean they rarely have good news anyway.
Friday, April 17, 2009
Super-hero league of Hollywood
So an interesting video that I had to share is the following. I found it on hulu.com. Now I know at first you would think a documentary about people who dress up in superhero outfits would be incredibly boring but it is in fact really interesting. The movie profiles four 'performers' in Hollywood who are trying to make it as actors or actresses and do this gig to just fill in the gaps.
It seems weird to imagine going to Hollywood to be a super-star. You hear about the people who never make it and how there are more all the time not making it and I think it was enlightening to hear a couple of the people's stories. It seems obvious that the underlying theme of the movie is that things are not working out. Two of the people are actually (or are shown to actually be) trying to get jobs whereas the other two are shown to not be. It seems like there is a disconnect between having a real plan and not having a plan at all for these people. However irrespective of that they all think they are going to make it and get noticed (which some might). It seems to me it is like winning the lotto by standing outside a store hoping someone will give you a winning ticket. Does not happen in real life but you never know. If you instead go in and buy the ticket you can at least have a chance of winning.
I can remember actually reading and hearing about Elmo and Mr. Incredible being arrested a while so it was weird to be seeing this from a second angle. They were arrested for disturbing the peace or something. Early in the movie about minute 6 I think there is a discussion about the laws surrounding what these costumed characters can and cannot do. (They basically work for tips but they cannot ask for tips or harass the tourists.) There was an interesting scene at about 13:30 where Marilyn Monroe was complaining about not getting tipped. She was complaining that no one paid her for a service that wasn't something that they had to pay for anyway and likened it to stealing. (Besides the fact that that analogy is incredibly wrong.) She was working for free with the hope that people would tip her. It seems counter intuitive to expect pay for that. The expectation that they would make tips regardless is detrimental. I have to hand it to superman (who probably makes a lot more than Ms. Monroe) as he was cool headed about it and was like, hey they don't have to pay us. I wonder what the economics of this situation is. You would need to be able to make enough that the average tip would be reasonable. However without enforcing the tipping you could have (as Ms. Monroe said) a string of people who don't tip because those before that they saw did not tip.
It is a surprisingly interesting video. At the end I felt mostly sad for all of the characters. It seems that this was partial due to the editing of the material but also because I do not feel that if they were really trying to make it that some of their decisions were not well-founded. (That is an opinion though.) I also have a major problem with people who expect tips which probably sullied my impression of a couple of the characters anyway. However I know one person (who does not read this blog who would be really interested in all of the superman memorabilia.)
It seems weird to imagine going to Hollywood to be a super-star. You hear about the people who never make it and how there are more all the time not making it and I think it was enlightening to hear a couple of the people's stories. It seems obvious that the underlying theme of the movie is that things are not working out. Two of the people are actually (or are shown to actually be) trying to get jobs whereas the other two are shown to not be. It seems like there is a disconnect between having a real plan and not having a plan at all for these people. However irrespective of that they all think they are going to make it and get noticed (which some might). It seems to me it is like winning the lotto by standing outside a store hoping someone will give you a winning ticket. Does not happen in real life but you never know. If you instead go in and buy the ticket you can at least have a chance of winning.
I can remember actually reading and hearing about Elmo and Mr. Incredible being arrested a while so it was weird to be seeing this from a second angle. They were arrested for disturbing the peace or something. Early in the movie about minute 6 I think there is a discussion about the laws surrounding what these costumed characters can and cannot do. (They basically work for tips but they cannot ask for tips or harass the tourists.) There was an interesting scene at about 13:30 where Marilyn Monroe was complaining about not getting tipped. She was complaining that no one paid her for a service that wasn't something that they had to pay for anyway and likened it to stealing. (Besides the fact that that analogy is incredibly wrong.) She was working for free with the hope that people would tip her. It seems counter intuitive to expect pay for that. The expectation that they would make tips regardless is detrimental. I have to hand it to superman (who probably makes a lot more than Ms. Monroe) as he was cool headed about it and was like, hey they don't have to pay us. I wonder what the economics of this situation is. You would need to be able to make enough that the average tip would be reasonable. However without enforcing the tipping you could have (as Ms. Monroe said) a string of people who don't tip because those before that they saw did not tip.
It is a surprisingly interesting video. At the end I felt mostly sad for all of the characters. It seems that this was partial due to the editing of the material but also because I do not feel that if they were really trying to make it that some of their decisions were not well-founded. (That is an opinion though.) I also have a major problem with people who expect tips which probably sullied my impression of a couple of the characters anyway. However I know one person (who does not read this blog who would be really interested in all of the superman memorabilia.)
Thursday, April 16, 2009
A post-modern proto-food
(Yes that is a reference to a specific book, brownie points to the person who can name it.)
So since I spent some time in Europe during my schooling years I have been interested in a complex and difficult to grasp concept of genetically modified (GM) foods (and vegetarianism with its relation to the GM foods). This post only deals with the former. The later will likely be discussed at length in the future.
Well, I will provide a couple of interesting videos about the subject before I continue. These are in general critical of GM foods (and genetic modification of our food supply) and probably rightly so, the flip side of the argument will be respected after the videos. The first video is from hulu.com. I just watched this documentary tonight, it repeats a lot that we will see in the other videos.
These next videos are from an investigative reporter in England. I have actually watched these a couple of times. They are worth watching just to see how a different culture (though not completely different) approaches the problem of food production (if not GM foods). Also the part where she goes into the chicken farm, creepy.
and part 2:
Finally I present a video that is a documentary about the history of corporations and the role of corporations in the current world. There is an interesting bit about Fox News, rBGH, and Monsanto in there. Definitely worth a watch as well. The playlist is here. The video is in 23 chapters. The following is the part about Fox News and rBGH.
Now all of these videos bring up a lot of interesting issues and in time I will try to come back to these issues. However I will only talk about the Food issues and specifically with regard to the GM foods. As I said these videos definitely have a slant which is worth pointing out. There is a political message in them that the actions of the corporations and the intents are in of themselves bad or poor. I think this is a slight misreading if not outright misunderstanding. If you watch the final video about the corporations in the US (and thus by extension the rest of the world) you will know that the corporation is bound, by law, to be self interested in profits for its shareholders. If it is not then the officers of the corporation are liable for the actions and can be sued by the shareholders.
Why is this important? As much as I dislike the idea of the patentability of life in any form (genes, bacteria, etc.) it is the system in which we live. In relation to crops, the companies saw a way to make money and are exploiting it. That is what they should do. Now there is a famous case in Canada (A?) about a canola farmer. The decision by the supreme court of Canada is in fact a very bad one. What happened is that some of the patented genes got onto this guy's farmland and crossbreed with his crop. So Monsanto allegedly went on his property and took samples and found this out. The supreme court ruled that it was his (the farmer who didn't even want GM foods) job to protect his crops from being cross pollinated with the patented crops. Which is a very insane judgment and completely impractical. I would direct someone with more interest to read the link or watch the entire first video. This strong arming by the corporation for unreasonable terms is not helping the corporation's cause in protecting their property. There are many examples of this happening and it huttles the real issues of government protection, corporation profit motivation, consumer's right to knowledge, and farmer's right to work.
At the heart, if the country decides that it is permissible for a corporation to own the rights to life in some way, it is important that laws are made to ensure the enforcement of zero liability in cases where the movement of the genetic material is unintended. If you are creating life there should be no expectation that you can own anything that is a derivative of that product which is substantially different. For instance if I make a butterfly and he mates with a squirrel, I should not own the flying squirrels. If this cannot be assured then there is problems (as there currently is). The question of the patentability of life is another topic for another time.
So why is this important? There is not currently proper labeling of GM foods in the United States (however there is in Europe, I mean Europe can get their act together why can't we?) and there has been a couple of times where this has caused health problems for the public. So what is the real issue in this debate? Really the european model is likely a more reasonable compromise. The government should enforce labeling of GM foods so the consumer will make intelligent decisions. However the corporations have said that customers will stay away from their product then and that will drop the price. THAT IS A GOOD THING YOU ANTI-CAPTIALIST CAPITALIST PIGS. :-) (I just had to, it was too easy.) If your product is deemed inferior then it will not get the same price as a product that is deemed superior. It would be like Microsoft saying that they should get a subsidy for all Zunes they sell so that they can get the same profit margins as Apple does on their iPod. If you produce a good product (non-GM foods) then you should be able to charge a higher price if the market will support it. It is a terrible argument to assume that it shouldn't work that way. Proper labeling will allow the customers to make wise (and healthy) decisions and if the GM foods are not what they want to eat, then well, you invested in the wrong technology and that isn't the consumer's fault. (Proceed to window two for your 'poor business decisions' bailout, you will notice the window because GM, Chrysler, AIG, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, Citigroup, Bank of America, among others are standing by the window.)
There is a more subtle problem with GM foods which is the big issue. What happens when the new mutations get out into the wild. What will the effect be on the eco-system. Now humans have been genetically manipulating food for thousands if not hundreds of thousands of years. Once mankind started farming, he took the best yielding, most resistant crops and cultivated those strains. The problem with the new GM foods is that the changes are so radical that there is no proper model for what that will do. In fact in Janurary there was a report which stated that the GM Soya product changes the genetic structure of the bacteria in the human intestines. What happens if that change results in flesh-eating bacteria? It is possible. There are flesh eating bacteria in the world. Maybe some bacteria have a dormant 'flesh-eating' protein next to a helpful 'make the food taste awesome by making it taste like mountain dew' gene. The GM company accidentally pulls both sequences into the new food and now both those genes are there. Doesn't give you a good feeling does it?
This is a complicated story which needs more rational and level-headed discussions on all sides instead of Gestapo tactics by the companies and misinformation spread by the anti-GM lobby. Has GM foods increased yields? No. Could it? Maybe. Should there be better laws? Yes. Should the courts respect a citizen's rights better? Yes (and not just in this case but in a lot of areas, like the New London decision). Should the FDA do more? Yes. Should corporations test their foods better before releasing them into the wild? Yes. Should we have better labeling? Yes. The fear, and it is a very real one, is that this issue has a possibility to completely change our world in sub-par ways before the government can work through the issues needed to properly understand and most likely regulate these issues. So, as people, it is important that we are read up and knowledgeable on these issues and developments so we can make rational and helpful decisions when it comes to the foods we eat.
So watch the videos especially the last one as it is VERY good. And just remember tomorrow when you are eating your Blueberry pancake and sausage on a stick from Jimmy Dean's, you never know if you are actually eating something made of fish guts and jellyfish, (well, I guess that was a bad example...).
So since I spent some time in Europe during my schooling years I have been interested in a complex and difficult to grasp concept of genetically modified (GM) foods (and vegetarianism with its relation to the GM foods). This post only deals with the former. The later will likely be discussed at length in the future.
Well, I will provide a couple of interesting videos about the subject before I continue. These are in general critical of GM foods (and genetic modification of our food supply) and probably rightly so, the flip side of the argument will be respected after the videos. The first video is from hulu.com. I just watched this documentary tonight, it repeats a lot that we will see in the other videos.
These next videos are from an investigative reporter in England. I have actually watched these a couple of times. They are worth watching just to see how a different culture (though not completely different) approaches the problem of food production (if not GM foods). Also the part where she goes into the chicken farm, creepy.
Adblock
and part 2:
Adblock
Finally I present a video that is a documentary about the history of corporations and the role of corporations in the current world. There is an interesting bit about Fox News, rBGH, and Monsanto in there. Definitely worth a watch as well. The playlist is here. The video is in 23 chapters. The following is the part about Fox News and rBGH.
Now all of these videos bring up a lot of interesting issues and in time I will try to come back to these issues. However I will only talk about the Food issues and specifically with regard to the GM foods. As I said these videos definitely have a slant which is worth pointing out. There is a political message in them that the actions of the corporations and the intents are in of themselves bad or poor. I think this is a slight misreading if not outright misunderstanding. If you watch the final video about the corporations in the US (and thus by extension the rest of the world) you will know that the corporation is bound, by law, to be self interested in profits for its shareholders. If it is not then the officers of the corporation are liable for the actions and can be sued by the shareholders.
Why is this important? As much as I dislike the idea of the patentability of life in any form (genes, bacteria, etc.) it is the system in which we live. In relation to crops, the companies saw a way to make money and are exploiting it. That is what they should do. Now there is a famous case in Canada (A?) about a canola farmer. The decision by the supreme court of Canada is in fact a very bad one. What happened is that some of the patented genes got onto this guy's farmland and crossbreed with his crop. So Monsanto allegedly went on his property and took samples and found this out. The supreme court ruled that it was his (the farmer who didn't even want GM foods) job to protect his crops from being cross pollinated with the patented crops. Which is a very insane judgment and completely impractical. I would direct someone with more interest to read the link or watch the entire first video. This strong arming by the corporation for unreasonable terms is not helping the corporation's cause in protecting their property. There are many examples of this happening and it huttles the real issues of government protection, corporation profit motivation, consumer's right to knowledge, and farmer's right to work.
At the heart, if the country decides that it is permissible for a corporation to own the rights to life in some way, it is important that laws are made to ensure the enforcement of zero liability in cases where the movement of the genetic material is unintended. If you are creating life there should be no expectation that you can own anything that is a derivative of that product which is substantially different. For instance if I make a butterfly and he mates with a squirrel, I should not own the flying squirrels. If this cannot be assured then there is problems (as there currently is). The question of the patentability of life is another topic for another time.
So why is this important? There is not currently proper labeling of GM foods in the United States (however there is in Europe, I mean Europe can get their act together why can't we?) and there has been a couple of times where this has caused health problems for the public. So what is the real issue in this debate? Really the european model is likely a more reasonable compromise. The government should enforce labeling of GM foods so the consumer will make intelligent decisions. However the corporations have said that customers will stay away from their product then and that will drop the price. THAT IS A GOOD THING YOU ANTI-CAPTIALIST CAPITALIST PIGS. :-) (I just had to, it was too easy.) If your product is deemed inferior then it will not get the same price as a product that is deemed superior. It would be like Microsoft saying that they should get a subsidy for all Zunes they sell so that they can get the same profit margins as Apple does on their iPod. If you produce a good product (non-GM foods) then you should be able to charge a higher price if the market will support it. It is a terrible argument to assume that it shouldn't work that way. Proper labeling will allow the customers to make wise (and healthy) decisions and if the GM foods are not what they want to eat, then well, you invested in the wrong technology and that isn't the consumer's fault. (Proceed to window two for your 'poor business decisions' bailout, you will notice the window because GM, Chrysler, AIG, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, Citigroup, Bank of America, among others are standing by the window.)
There is a more subtle problem with GM foods which is the big issue. What happens when the new mutations get out into the wild. What will the effect be on the eco-system. Now humans have been genetically manipulating food for thousands if not hundreds of thousands of years. Once mankind started farming, he took the best yielding, most resistant crops and cultivated those strains. The problem with the new GM foods is that the changes are so radical that there is no proper model for what that will do. In fact in Janurary there was a report which stated that the GM Soya product changes the genetic structure of the bacteria in the human intestines. What happens if that change results in flesh-eating bacteria? It is possible. There are flesh eating bacteria in the world. Maybe some bacteria have a dormant 'flesh-eating' protein next to a helpful 'make the food taste awesome by making it taste like mountain dew' gene. The GM company accidentally pulls both sequences into the new food and now both those genes are there. Doesn't give you a good feeling does it?
This is a complicated story which needs more rational and level-headed discussions on all sides instead of Gestapo tactics by the companies and misinformation spread by the anti-GM lobby. Has GM foods increased yields? No. Could it? Maybe. Should there be better laws? Yes. Should the courts respect a citizen's rights better? Yes (and not just in this case but in a lot of areas, like the New London decision). Should the FDA do more? Yes. Should corporations test their foods better before releasing them into the wild? Yes. Should we have better labeling? Yes. The fear, and it is a very real one, is that this issue has a possibility to completely change our world in sub-par ways before the government can work through the issues needed to properly understand and most likely regulate these issues. So, as people, it is important that we are read up and knowledgeable on these issues and developments so we can make rational and helpful decisions when it comes to the foods we eat.
So watch the videos especially the last one as it is VERY good. And just remember tomorrow when you are eating your Blueberry pancake and sausage on a stick from Jimmy Dean's, you never know if you are actually eating something made of fish guts and jellyfish, (well, I guess that was a bad example...).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)